Credit: The gorgeous image above: “Blah Blah Blah” by Mel Bochner, 2012.
Twitter 10k – what’s all this?
Twitter was all a flutter last week with a mooted change in the product, see #Twitter10k. Currently there is a 140 character limit for updates and a 10,000 character limit for Direct Messages. Reports surfaced of plans to extend the 10k character limit to your newsfeed!
Whether this was a kite flying exercise or timed to coincide with CES2016 only time will tell. According to Re/Code, who broke the story, Twitter is planning to launch the new 10k character limit by the end of Q1. That’s the end of March 2016 for the rest of us.
We previously wrote about the direction Twitter might take at the end of last year (our article also featured on the burgeoning Irish Tech News). A tentative first step in 2016 in attracting new users looks to be increasing the character limit beyond the sacred 140!
Jack Dorsey admits that “140 character has become a beautiful constraint … It inspires creativity and brevity. And a sense of speed.” We among many others would definitely agree!
He also said they were flagging this so developers could prepare in advance. He finished his update below by saying he loved a tweetstorm, and in fairness who doesn’t!
— Jack (@jack) January 5, 2016
Twitter 10k – the case against:
Ecoconsultancy quickly published a 5 reasons why increasing the character limit on Twitter to 10k was a bad idea. Namely:
- The change will cause Twitter to lose it’s USP (Unique Selling Point).
- That brevity is best: 140 character limit (and 120 if you want a retweet!) encourages creative, witty, pitchy writing. It is also great skill to help you craft better headlines for articles. Undoing this cap encourages long windedness.
- There’s a danger that twitter will lose it’s ‘live’ feeling: The Arab Spring, Hurricane Desmond, and its fast following cousins Eva and Frank, Water Charges Protests, Marriage Equality Referendum, Bataclan/ Paris attacks, Charlie Hebdo, Black Lives Matter … all benefitted from the short live updates on Twitter by those witnessing on the ground. Twitter is the go to resource for this fast flowing information – what impact will an increased character count have here?
- Twitter could become a sea of ‘marketing slurry’ (!): Point 2 above deals with the ability to pitch an idea, service, observation or concept in a short attention grabbing way. The fear here is that the whole, at times poorly written, press release gets lobbed onto Twitter.
- It’s just a really weird thing to do – this seemed to be forced in there to make up a magic 5th reason, all good listicles need 5 elements!
According to Mashable Wall St also thought that a Twitter 10k character limit was a bad idea and its stock was down 2% the day the story broke.
Twitter 10k – the case for:
Twitter has picked up on the trend of users bypassing its current character limit by posting images with longer text, Jack’s own tweet above on the subject is a good example of this.
Customer support responses currently often entail multiple responses to a query due to the current character limit, a 10k limit will allow one consolidated response. (However, a long winded debate or troll can possibly become even more long winded!)
We carried out a Twitter poll last week and 83% of respondents reckoned that a Twitter 10k character limit would make the newsfeed unreadable.
— DotDash (@DotDashOne) January 6, 2016
Getting the design and implementation right for the new Twitter 10k feature will be critical, with successes so far evident in the introduction of polls, video and multiple images into users feed.
When the new Twitter 10k character limit is introduced it is hard to imagine Twitter’s developers implementing this in a clumsy or cack-handed way. It is unlikely they would allow reams of text to clutter up its product and your feed, it is therefore likely that any change would be similar to the ‘view summary’ feature currently on the site.
All websites wish to keep impressions within their own walled garden; that rings true for Facebook, Twitter or your own business website. In this respect it makes sense for Twitter to try to do this with longer form content.
The great challenge in all of this for Twitter in future is striking a balance between alienating core users and attracting new ones to the fold.
We feel if the new 10k character limit is introduced it will be integrated in a clear but unobtrusive way. The #Twitter10k topic was trending on Twitter last Wednesday (06/01/16) and many of those users were asking for an edit button first.
What was that Oscar Wilde said about being talked about versus not being talked about?