Rogue 1: A Star Wars Story – A spoiler free review

By @SimonCocking – a spoiler free review.

It’s out. We’re now into the era of a Star Wars movie for Christmas, possibly for ever, or at least for the next three years, as well as the last two including this one. Having recently re-watched the prequel trilogy in the series this could  be a truly awful state of affairs…

Fortunately it seems that in selling the franchise to Disney, George Lucas may have done us all, himself included, a great favour. For starters, last year’s reboot, ‘The Force Awakens’ say it quietly, wasn’t actually that bad. Now for all of those of us who have watched I, II and III, it wouldn’t be unfair to say that expectations (mine at least) were extremely low after the awful (Jar Jar Binks?) and the plain creepy (Anakin going from being a 5 year old pod racer prodigy, to a moody teenager, to the stalker who sired Luke and Leia …).

So, 12 months later, here came the ultimate in filler. Something to keep us going, while they edited all those lovely green and grey Skellig island shots into something meaningful. What would it be like? How bad would it be? Especially as we had heard of none of these characters, as by definition this was a bit of a story squeezed in between III and IV to fill in the gaps.

Except. They got a great, young, promising director, Gareth Edwards, who made the pretty good ‘Monsters’ 2010 -> check it out, it was good, on a low low budget. The lead actress, Felicity Jones, was also very good in Chalet Girl, and Diego Luna, also very good in Y tu mama tambien and Milk among other films. Not to mention the always edgy but cool Forrest Whitaker who gave a great cameo – was he inspired by Dennis Hopper in Blue Velvet? Overall the cast was good, cool, and got on with it. We were saved the stagy awkward Padme / Anakin romance, or even the pretty telegraphed plot story lines in A New Hope. I have no insights into the plot of Star Wars VIII but I’m pretty sure Rey may discover her parents are more famous than she thought …

Thankfully Rogue One has none of these plot legacies to have to deal with. Instead it is a rip roaring, get them in, set them up, and watch the sparks fly as they chase the elusive treasure. The longer it went on, the more it felt like we had slipped into a space mashup of The Dirty Dozen, the Magnificent Seven, Kelly’s Heroes and naturally the Seven Samurai. Ultimately we all know that it must end somewhere just before Star Wars IV (the original movie) begins, but how we get to that point becomes an insane, joyous, explosive, elemental journey.

When the dust finally set I was just a little traumatised at what had come to pass. At the same time I was relieved that they had completed a great little episode that sits happily within the wider Star Wars canon. Certainly better than all three of the prequel trilogies, and possibly less uneven than some of the first three movies too. Go see it, with your kids, and try not to let them see that you were perhaps even just a little bit moved.


If you would like to have your company featured in the Irish Tech News Business Showcase, get in contact with us at Simon@IrishTechNews.net or on Twitter: @SimonCocking

Simon Cocking

Recent Posts

Transition Year Students and Women’s Collective Ireland Participants Graduate from Maynooth University STEM Inclusion Programme

Participants from Women’s Collective Ireland (WCI), Ronanstown, along with 319 Transition Year (TY) students from…

7 hours ago

NovaUCD and CeADAR Open Applications for 2026 AI Ecosystem Accelerator Programme

NovaUCD and CeADAR today announced that they are seeking applications from Irish-based AI start-ups to…

9 hours ago

Building a big ‘time crystal’ on IBM Quantum Heron

Researchers created a large, complex, two-dimensional “time crystal” on an IBM Quantum Heron r2 chip,…

11 hours ago

DeepWind, the new deepwater test site for offshore wind,

The European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC) has commenced an 18 month project to advance its…

13 hours ago

Microsoft launches 2026 Community Fund for South and West Dublin

Minister of State at the Department of Justice with special responsibility for Migration, and Dublin…

14 hours ago

How the 35% R&D Tax Credit Boosts Ireland’s MedTech R&D and Innovation Pipeline

Ireland’s MedTech sector is one of the country’s standout success stories. Ireland is home to…

1 day ago

More about Irish Tech News


Irish Tech News are Ireland’s No. 1 Online Tech Publication and often Ireland’s No.1 Tech Podcast too.


You can find hundreds of fantastic previous episodes and subscribe using whatever platform you like via our Anchor.fm page here: https://anchor.fm/irish-tech-news


If you’d like to be featured in an upcoming Podcast email us at Simon@IrishTechNews.ie now to discuss.


Irish Tech News have a range of services available to help promote your business. Why not drop us a line at Info@IrishTechNews.ie now to find out more about how we can help you reach our audience.


You can also find and follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and Snapchat.